A Tale of two Dals - Makhani & Bukhara

Dal Makhani is one of the cornerstones of Punjabi cuisine and is quite a popular but heavy dish. It goes down fantastically well with some soft butter kulchas (best at Masala Kraft,Taj) and some Kingfisher on the side.It is a simple dish with a ordinary ingredients but a true dal makhani like other well made Punjabi dishes has to be simmered for up to 8 hours to get it right

Dal Makhani

When you taste a well made Dal makhani you bite into the taste of the dal accented by the taste and smell of gobs of butter which goes right to your brain. Best places for Dal Makhani - Moti Mahal at Cr2 / Dum Pukth at ITC Grand Maratha / Masala Kraft at the Taj.

Dal Bukhara is an elusive cousin of the Dal Makhani. Bukhara is a town in modern day Uzbekista, not sure how well the two are connected. I would reckon that the Bukhara dal is a North West Frontier province dish and somehow traveled to India via the silk route.

However it is pretty rare to find Dal Bukhara on the menu in the myriad restaurants around the city. Usual preference for dal has been Dal Makhani, even in the upper end restaurants. So the chances of you having a well made Dal Bukhara is just slightly less than finding a regular Dal Bukhara for a meal.

It is sort of the like the Dal Makhani but complicated by the use of a red tomato gravy as the base for the cooking and the taste of butter not being essential to its experience. The tomato adds a tang in the daal and gives it a taste and look (reddish, brownish) different from the black Dal Makhani.

Dal Bukhara

The best example i have had has been at the Royal Challenge restaurant in Goregaon W on the way to Film City.

One of the worlds best restaurants (ranked 37th) The Bukhara at the ITC, Delhi also does a version, apparently simmered for 24 hours on a slow flame. I have a trip to Delhi planned later this year, which is pretty much built around sampling the cuisine of this restaurant, chiefly the dal bukhara.

  • 0
  • 0

Crumbs [7]

Hey Gaurav

u r right as i m from punjab and i know what Dal Makhni mean there.Every Order the people placed Dal Makhni should b there.
u r right Preparation of Dal Makhni take 8 to 9 hours. There is Dabha in Ludhiana (Punjab) whose Dal Makhni is World Famous.
people from Ludhiana and surroundings used to visit Dabha only for Dal Makhni.

kunal June 14th, 2007

gaurav u got the dal makhni right but u have some confusion with dal bukhara and my dear all your confusions will end once you eat at BUKHARA at the ITC MAURYA SHERATON in Delhi.

You wil forget every other dal which u have eaten in the past.

vikas August 16th, 2007

either way…they both are delicious!!

trupti December 6th, 2008

ITS JUST NOT A DAL MAKHNI. THERE IS DIFFERENCE IN DAL MAKHNI & DAL MAKHNI BUKHARA. THE TASTE ,THE COLOR,THE AFTER EFFECT AND THE RICHNESS IN IT MAKES IT DIFFERENT FROM ALL OTHER DALS.MAJOR DIFFERENCE IS THE PASSION TO COOK DAL MAKHNI BUKHARA. MUST TRY IT ONCE IF U WANNA FILTER OUT THE DIFFERENCE. ITS YUMMY

MANJU MALHOTRA November 9th, 2009

Manju,

i have had both dals, quite often and would be foolish if i wrote about the two without having tasted both.

both the dals are different from each other and i have pointed out the differences in their construction.

as for the passion, well thats a nice thing to have but its no gurantee of good taste.

Gaurav November 12th, 2009

omg i would die if dal makhani wud dissapear from the face of ths earth smday!

shubham baliyan April 11th, 2010

Have tried numerous versions of the Dal at different restaurants.. But nothing comes close to the Dal at Bukhara at ITC Maurya ! Its absolutely the best !

akzephyr August 18th, 2010

Post your crumb

Crumbs: (Required)
Name: (Required)
Email: (Required)
Website


Articles by this Author

Related Articles

What's Hot



Subscribe to blah!

Via RSS
Latest Articles in your RSS Reader

Today's Poll